'Teen Mom' is an American show for MTV that follows a select number of girls through their early years as parents. We first met these girls in the original show '16 and Pregnant' where we saw their pregnancies and labor stories unfold. I've watched this show from the beginning. At first my son wasn't even a twinkle in my eye when I was watching and then I fell pregnant and had my son, and also only being a few years older than the girls in the cast meant I felt an affinity with them.
The show itself has drawn a huge amount of criticism. I think that's mostly because of the way everyone perceives teenager mothers to be. And perhaps not even just teenagers mothers, young mothers (like me) get it too. If you are a young mother, but mostly if you are a teenage mother than you are judged, stereotyped against and forced to face open criticisim about your ability to parent properly based only on your age-nothing about your personality or personal abilities, just your age. The cast of 'Teen Mom' chose to be part of a compelling series which means they are often heaped with an entire worlds worth of young parent criticisim when actually what they have done is shown the true and real picture that faces a teenage mother.
The picture of what it looks like to be a teen mum, isn't an easy one. The statistics are there, lets not ignore them-we known teen mum's are 22% more likely to live in poverty and 20% less likely to have any qualifications by the time they are 30 years old. However does this mean that they are all bad parents? Even if you base your 'bad parenting' assessment on the 20% more likely to live in poverty, that still means 80% of them AREN'T living in poverty and 78% of them WILL have qualifications by the time they are 30. I don't think that's too bad considering if you deal with sleepless nights, and everything else parenthood throws at you at the ages of 16 and 17 years old!
The cast of 'Teen Mom' have been accused of glamorizing teen pregnancy. I can only assume the people who make those accusations haven't even seen the show! I've watched these girls go through teenage trials and tribulations at the same time as the mummy trials and tribulations-it's a double whammy. I can't imagine going through my teenage angst years, facing all the confusion, discovery, heartache and wondering at the same time as all the stress, worry and adaption that occurs when you have a child. The cast of the show have shared their stories and this is what all of them have in common-the loss of their childhood at the same time as their arrival in to parenthood.
![]() |
| Maci Bookout |
Some of the girls have taken to motherhood very well, they are dependable, financially secure on their own, sensible and great role models. Yes you read that correctly, great role models. I'm talking about Maci Bookout, the mother of Bentley who fell pregnant at 16 after having sex just once. She and Bentley's daddy separated very soon after Bentley was born and you watched her struggle with the relationship as the daddy couldn't adjust and she strived to provide the best for her child. She's worked hard, got herself through university, provided for her son and built a good foundation with her family and Bentley's father to ensure she's doing the very best that she possibly can. Then there is Catelynn and her long time partner Tyler, who fell pregnant at 16 and knew they couldn't provide any sense of a normal life for their daughter and made the painful decision to have her adopted in order for her to have the life she deserved. Their heartache over missing their daughters life is utterly poignant and yet they do it, they go through it, because it's what is truly best for their child.
![]() |
| Catelynn and Tyler |
Don't get me wrong, they aren't perfect examples of parenthood. One of the girls, Farrah, has some very large emotional issues and a severe lack of respect for her parents despite their constant support, love and assistance in co-parenting her own daughter Sophia. Then there is Chelsea who's financially lucky enough to be kept by her dad, he got her a car, house etc and gives her plenty of money to live on. Sounds great but her daughters father is an absolute idiot who treats her and their daughter Aubree appallingly, flitting in and out of their lives constantly and providing heartache and disappointment that would be hard for a teenager to bare let along a mother, on behalf of her child.
![]() |
| Farrah and baby Sophia |
There are also several girls who just can't cope with early motherhood. The actions of drug addicted Amber who eventually lost custody of her daughter Leah to her Father, but had so many deep emotional scars I couldn't see it going any other way. And the likes of Jenelle who's also a drug addict, in and out of jail and who's mother has custody of her son and has raised him pretty much herself since the beginning as Jenelle couldn't make the adaption from teenager to mother. Refusing to leave behind her days of drugs and partying despite having a son.
None of these girls have had it easy. They all go through pain, disappointment and resentment and have to deal with the physical, mental and relationship damage that having a child in your teens can cause with their partners, friends and families. They not only have to go through this themselves, but also for their children because as we all know-"a mother always has to think twice-once for herself and once for her child" and that applies no matter what age you are. It's also hard to imagine the difficulties they face being attached to an ex partner for life. When I think of my teenage boyfriends, I could shudder at the thought of having them in my life forever and yet these girls have to face a life time relationship with people they would rather have moved on from.
However in their stories I see girls who have matured immensely, taken on roles that older mother struggle with, and run with them. I think a positive for a teen mum is that they have had less time to get used to a life of their own and so it's easier to adapt to a new life as a mother-loosely speaking anyway. And although they all have to come to terms with loosing their childhood and leaving behind their teenage years, they all give it the best shot they can. Sometimes it's enough and sometimes it isn't, but hey isn't that parenthood in general, regardless of age?
Along with this show and the likes of the very lovely Cupcake Mumma, (who had her daughter in her late teens) I have really changed my personal perceptions of teenage mothers. I still wouldn't say I'm all for teenage pregnancy-who in their right mind would?! But what I do say is that I don't think the criticism and judgments a teenage mother will face are always correctly targeted. Some of them are good parents, some are great parents and some are better parents than most others-they aren't all bad.
As for glamorizing teenage pregnancy, it's laughable because the USA now has an all time low figure of teenage pregnancy and most people think shows like 'Teen Mom' are a part of that. These shows tell the story of girls who loose so much of themselves before they even know who they are or what they are loosing, their naivety and childhood is pulled from beneath them, barely any of their relationships work out (totally dispels those who think having a baby will make their boyfriend stay forever) they struggle financially (there goes a 'good' idea of living off the state) and they loose friendships and relationships as they battle the loneliness and isolation that normal parenthood directs. And that's without the added stereotypes going against you as a teen mum.
Parenthood means doing your best and if you lack on age, you are certainly coming at it from a different angle. But does that necessarily mean that your direction will cause you to fail? My opinion is that although I wish teenage pregnancy didn't happen, it does and it will but I don't think a persons age is paramount to their ability or inability to parent. We can all but do our best, like I said-sometimes it's enough and sometimes it isn't.
Love Chloe xx




I love Teen Mom and have watched it from the start. I really don't think it glamorises teen pregnancy, more raises awareness of the struggles these mums go through. Great post!
ReplyDeleteAh I wasn't expecting to see my name! Thank you haha you had me hooked on this post and i agree with a lot of what you have said. I was indeed a teen mum at the age o 17 (18 when dd came along) and it was incredibly hard going, i dont think i have blogged honestly about the ins and outs of it all, maybe i should.
ReplyDeleteYou are also right in regards to the falling rates in usa and the rising rates in the uk..what are we doing wrong? Fab post thanks xx
Love Teen Mom, saw the other day that Farrah is now modeling for at top agengy.
ReplyDeletexx
Mate my mother would have killed me if I had even had sex before 16 let alone had a baby as a teenager. I think some teenagers cope very well and probably make good parents however it isnt what I would wish for my child. Take care, Kate (aka Makeshift Mummy) xx
ReplyDeletePersonally I think they say the show glamourizes teen preganacy because of the idea they (the teenages) believe they may get on the show, type of deal. Fame is a powerful motivator to angst ridden teens.
ReplyDeleteI believe the ones on the show are "accidents", but teens not on the show that are not in front of the camera may have had other ideas.
I was a young mother at 21 and their is nothing glamourous about it. Now at 26 with 2 young boys I am very happpy, alot more finacilly secure, and glad I had my struggle with college. All these things have made me a better person, and now I am able to enjoy my boys. When I am 31 I will have a 10yr old and a 6 yr old... Lots of women will just be starting. This I am thankful for.
I had Alex when I was 19 (6 days off being 20 I might add ;))and have been subject to a few dirty looks and opinions, lots of people thought I looked much younger than I actually was which didn't help! But I don't think me and my partner have done too badly for ourselves. If I didn't have such a stable relationship in the first place I'd imagine it would be very different and probably wouldn't cope too well, guess I am just lucky in that respect. There's part of me that felt it all happened too young and me and my partner haven't had a holiday abroad together or gone out partying as such, but to be honest I have always wanted to be a mum so that doesn't bother me too much. Advantage of being a young Mum is that you can have the freedom again in your late 30's anyway :)
ReplyDeleteI used to watch the 'Teen Mom's' loads, unfortunately we had to get rid of sky so don't have MTV any more! But when I used to watch the hardships they went through I am thankful that I wasn't quite as young, as personally I don't think you are mature enough then, but like you say it certainly doesn't make you a bad mother either. I am sure there are plenty of great/not so great Mums no matter what age you are anyway x
I had my first child at 23 but I look much younger and teenagers these days look much older. The baby group i first went to was for 'young mums' and it felt so very patronising with its age limit. Personally I think that these comments and looks only bother you because you allow them too. Who cares what others think it's their rubbish to deal with. If you do the best by your children, whoever you are, however old you are, 14 or 54 then that's all you can do - age certainly doesn't make you a better or worse mother or father. I kicked up a fuss about the label of the young mums group and they changed the name to Monday Mums. I did this because actually after having a child it didn't matter that I was only 23, I was in the same boat as every other new mother 16 or 35+ . When a baby is born a mother is too no matter their age...
ReplyDeletep.s. everything I have said is meant in generally not specifically directed to you Chloe :) xx
Ah Chloe thanks for this post, you know how I feel about this subject. I was 23 days off being 19 when I had Jared, and I have had such a hard time in my experience in being a young Mummy. Dirty looks, whispers, even rude comments, just purely based on my age- it didn't matter than my son was happily chatting away, in his nice clothes in his nice pram, all they cared about was that I was 19. I know I look about 17 in reality, but even if I was younger, so what, they were basically overlooking the fact that my baby was happy and healthy just because I'm younger. I hate the stereotype of a "young parent" and I'm sick to the back teeth of trying to get my voice heard that not all of us young Mummy's fit into this awful stereotype! I do know people who have fit into this category, and I see them everyday when I go into town, but I don't think that we should all be tarnished with the same brush! I am the best Mummy I could be, just like I would be if I was 25, 35, 45! It is extremely difficult being a young Mum, not only do you have to deal with everything else any Mum has to go through, prgnancy, birth, adapting to your new life as a parent etc, you have to deal with all the negative backlash from people who don't even know you, but seem to think they have a right to judge your life!
ReplyDeleteI love Teen Mom too, and I don't think it glamourises teen pregnancy- it shows just how damn hard it can be! Catelynn and Tyler are definately my favourites, I know how hard it was for them to give Carly away, but they shown how mature they were by giving her to people who could look after her physically, emotionally and financially. Farrah to me, was a massive brat when 16 and Pregnant first aired, but she does seem to have matured, and you can tell how much Sophia means to her. Amber I cannot stand, whenever we see her she's lying in bed or in the couch, either on her phone flirting with some guy or texting a friend, or arguing with Gary over something or other. I do feel sorry for her as she is obviously depressive and has some emotional problems, but she should be getting help, not causing trouble, especially not while her little girl is there!
Anyway, great post, this is something I feel very passionately about! xx
I've never seen this! Will defo check it out though, I can't get enough of baby/pregnancy shows on tv xxx
ReplyDeletegreat post...I was a young mom too...however I was married and in my early 20's and I got looks all the time-people questioned how old I was all the time-just rude at times. I am a new follower!!
ReplyDeleteI love that programme. My sister had her first baby at 18, and is a great mum, yes it was hard for her especially as she ended up splitting with the babies dad but she is a fab mum and my niece Chloe is 17 now and is so beautiful and clever(proud auntie alert!). My sister is now happily married, living in her own home and had her 5th baby last year.
ReplyDeleteI think its easy to look down on teen mums and yes some are not great but then older mums aren't all great either.
i watched this program from the start, and got a little obsessed with the storys, even trawling the net for the catch up shows before they were shown in the uk. Catelynn and Tylers story made me cry every time. there so brave its amazing. myself being 19 when i had harry was brandished a 'teen mum' but im hardly sterotypical of it. been with partner 7yrs and a stable home life, money stituation stable etc etc, didnt stop me being treated like absolute scum by hospitals etc :( x
ReplyDeleteI love this show! Maci was my absolute favourite I think she has done a great job with her son :)
ReplyDeleteI love this show too!
ReplyDeleteThanks for following Rock Paper Scissors Create, I'm following back:)